1994, Sister was honored with the American College of Nurse-Midwives' Hattie Hemschemeyer Award for her distinguished and exceptional achievements in nurse-midwifery. Of her own expression of the Medical Mission Sisters' mission of healing presence, Sister Catherine has said, "It's just the day-to-day contact you hope the Lord helps you to have with each person...and helps them to realize how wonderful they are." At the time of her death, Sister Catherine Shean was retired from active ministry and living in St. Joseph's Manor in Philadelphia.